Each of these scenes has a meaning beyond the obvious, however. Food s equated with life and excitement, two subjects into which this story pursues. Sex, food and magic are mixed in sparingly in the story, which revolves about Tita, third daughter of a Elena. From Nacha and her mother Tita learns the art of cooking.
While all the food did not center around Tita, ost of it was. Even from the time of birth of Tita she was a part of the cooking, for example when she was born and Nacha scooped up the salt left behind from the broken water of Mama Elena after the birth of Tita. SparkTeach Teacher's Handbook. Mini Essays Suggested Essay Topics.
Previous section Suggested Reading. Test your knowledge Take the Context Quick Quiz. Popular pages: Like Water for Chocolate. That Tita achieves personal fulfillment only in death harks back to the stereotypical long, suffering woman. There are other secondary and peripheral characters that are worthy of examining in establishing the hacienda as a microcosm of Mexican society.
Within the novel, Chencha is both the voice and victim of the physical violence occurring during this era. Her reports about the revolution, although exaggerated, bring the brutality of the revolution into the hacienda. Esquivel 14 This is omitted from the adaptation.
The construction of her character, in the adaptation, is reduced to almost caricature status within the hacienda, serving as victim and friend to Tita. Even the severity of the attack on Chencha by American bandits is sidestepped in the film version. The economic effects of the revolution are further de-emphasized in the film version with the omission of the Chinese merchant character who, in the novel, becomes wealthy from trade between the Northern frontier and Mexico City.
The construction of characters and their adaptations from novel to film place, to some extent, the immediacy of the Revolution, especially the violence and brutality typically associated with it, at a distance. The revolution is subsumed into the subjective experience of oppression, conflict, and resolution that elevates the personal, subjective experience over the social turmoil The question that this raises is how then does the film portray an image of Mexico and its past?
The Revolution is subsumed into events at the hacienda at the same time that those events are invested with revolutionary ideals that are just as universal in their appeal as they are Mexican. The epic in Like Water for Chocolate can be defined in terms of the intergenerational structure, the outcome of which is the great-niece as both narrator and a product of the reconciliation phase of the Mexican Revolution.
Family history is made epic in the construction of the narrative and through the stylized presentation. The construction of aesthetic space in creating the epic nature of the film also crosses geopolitical borders. His mannerisms, quirky facial gestures, and glasses deny him the machismo traits bestowed to Pedro.
The construction of masculinity within both novel and film is of particular interest in terms of the cross-border appeal and feminine appropriation of mexicanidad on one hand and subsumation of this into a modern national identity on the other.
This pertains to the triangular formation between Tita, Pedro, and John. Contrasted to the Mexicans, his Spanish is terrible; however, his use of English lends an international aspect to the overall film. Contrasted to Pedro, his effeminate qualities diminish his masculinity. The episode of Tita in the United States is not about John Brown, but about temporary Mexican displacement in order to improve living conditions, one that could symbolize Mexican migration for economic reasons in a contemporary context.
This needs to be understood in terms of specific sequences that inform his relationship with Tita. During the watermelon sequence, the restless heat of environment transforms into his seduction of Tita against the wall. The concern then becomes at what cost to the formation of identity is this achieved? Alfonso Arau creates an interesting critique of the Manifest Destiny early in the film, one that figuratively and literally foreshadows later events in the narrative.
As John Brown explains to Tita human spirituality through the metaphor of matches, he shows her illustrations of the tunnel, a consequence of burning all the matches at once.
The issue of Manifest Destiny lays in the intermarriage of the two nationalities embodied in Alex and Esperanza, the product of which is the narrator. Addressing the spectator in perfect Spanish and professing that her Christmas rolls are not as good as her mother, what is the female Mexican if not la raza cosmic?
Is it this cultural hybridity predicated upon two clashing culinary techniques with the mexicanidad dying out? These are questions left open by the text. The reaction of each woman to her predicament helps delineate their differing characters.
Whereas Mama Elena lets the loss of love turn her into a sinister and domineering mother, Tita, while obeying her mother's command outwardly, engages in a lifelong struggle for love, which she eventually wins through the strength of spirit.
The structuring of Like Water for Chocolate as "A Novel in Monthly Installments with Recipes, Romances, and Home Remedies," as it is subtitled, establishes the filter through which the reader will experience the world of the novel. Like Tita--whose knowledge of life is "based on the kitchen"-- the reader must explore the work through the role and power of food, guided by the recipes that begin each chapter. The division of the novel into "monthly installments" conjures up the image of serial narratives published in periodicals often women's magazines.
This organization, along with the matter-of-fact weaving of recipes and remedies into the fabric of the narrative, underscores the fact that the novel offers substantial opportunities for feminist analysis.
In addition to serving as a central organizing principle, food is often a direct cause of physical and emotional unrest, and serves as a medium through which emotions can be transmitted. Tita prepares most of the food in the novel, and she uses food to express her emotions because her lowly cultural status affords her no other opportunity to do so.
The vomiting and moroseness at Rosaura's wedding results from the guests' eating the cake that bears Tita's tears.
0コメント